Cecil Adams knocks down the urban legend of James Bartley, who allegedly survived being swallowed whole by a whale. While humans can hypothetically fit down a whale's throat, there doesn't appear to be any record of survival in doing so: suffocation would be an issue, if not stomach acid.
You know how really obsessive fans of tv shows will
construct elaborate explanations to reconcile continuity errors made by the writers? Yeah, there are whole Bible websites devoted to the same concept, and they have to resort to "It was a miracle!" to
explain Jonah, which in my mind is further evidence of the absence of evidence of modern-day whale-swallowee survivors. The nice thing about religious literature is that the reader can't legitimately complain about the use of
deus ex machina.
(Such plot contrivances explain my problem with "Buffy" and the last three seasons of "The West Wing," my reluctance to start watching "Lost," and why I suspect I will be ultimately disappointed by "Heroes.")
Entertainingly, the site refuses to accept the story of Jonah as an allegory, but is happy to explain away "three days and three nights" as "perhaps as little as 38 hours," the sort of hairsplitting I thought was unique to Talmudic traditions and
Louisiana judges.