The war on the Christian adoption of the winter-solstice pagan ritual of the Vedic solar deity Mithra
I was precociously pugnacious. Made militant in resentment of the public-school kindergarten teacher who read the class the story of Jesus and the first-graders who insisted my Santa Claus skepticism was a reflection of my Judaism, by the second grade I was refusing to participate in the Christmas pageant. I wasn't even happy with the proposed compromise solution of letting me sing the dreydel song with the fourth-graders: I knew the qualitative difference between a token song about a toy and a song about the three wise men. This wasn't even a Newdow situation; I think my parents were mortified that I was causing problems when it was hard enough to avoid penalty for taking Yom Kippur off. A legitimate attack of the flu, however, prevented me from being disruptive and getting a mark on my permanent record.
I disliked the season. The malls were ridiculously crowded, every tv show (in the three-network era, at least) was about Christmas, every PA system and commercial was playing the same damned infernal tinkling twelve songs, and newscasters and other adults who showed no concern about my Judaism the other eleven months of the year were suddenly wishing me a happy Hanukkah. The day itself, my friend Greg would get all sorts of cool presents, and I would free-ride off the surplusage of new Atari games, but otherwise, I couldn't stand it.
Years later, I was dating a smart Gentile lawyer with a sexy Texan accent. Very nice woman who's gone on to be quite successful, but there were four separate incidents that made me realize that we just weren't going to be compatible, all of which are of a Seinfeldian eating-peas-with-a-fork quality, and one of them was the December date where she showed up at my door in a sweater with a reindeer-sleigh pattern to take me to a Christmas movie that wasn't "Gremlins."
Somehow, this incident didn't even occur to me when I got married nine months after first meeting my first wife in a February, and quickly found the absence of a Christmas tree to be a source of conflict where I really should've been the one to give in. Or not, because it's really for the best that my stubbornness on that issue probably accelerated the end of that ill-considered marriage.
The interesting thing about the overstated Fox News pounding of the drums in defense against a fictitious attack on Christmas is that it's pulled the Christmas-haters out of the woodwork. Or, perhaps, created a controversy where none was before, emboldening the press to publish "both sides" of the issue, and we now see a lot of anti-Christmas writings where before we wouldn't see any.
So, I give you:
Christopher Hitchens on Christmas as a dictatorial blot where the US briefly turns into North Korea ("an insistent din of identical propaganda and identical music"); Steven Landsburg
defends Scrooge; and Amber Taylor
condemning the coniferous aspects of the holiday. And, for equal balance, how
Hanukkah screwed up the Jewish psyche, though I would've preferred seeing something criticizing dreydels as a choking hazard.
Yet somehow, I'm looking forward to this December 25 more than any other I can remember.
Speaking of Seinfeldian, have a
Happy Festivus for those of you celebrating it today.